72ND Eatery Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to 72ND Eatery, a delightful spot located at 261 Columbus Ave, New York, NY. This eatery stands out for its commitment to fresh, homemade meals that cater to various tastes.
The menu boasts an enticing selection of favorite sandwiches, including the hickory smoked turkey pita and avocado BLT club, all priced reasonably at around $12.95. For those craving heartier options, the organic rotisserie chicken served with two sides at $10.95 is a must-try!
- Potato Chips: Choose between veggie chips, Cape Cod, or Doritos starting at $1.95.
- Breakfast: Enjoy affordable breakfast sandwiches that don’t skimp on flavor.
- Customer Favorites: Rave reviews highlight giant portions, fresh ingredients, and exceptional service.
Whether in a hurry or seeking a satisfying meal, 72ND Eatery offers a memorable dining experience that leaves you eager to return.
Potato Chips
Baked Lays Chips
Original, sour cream and onion.
Veggie Chips
Vegetarian. Garden veggie straws, rosemary, olive oil.
Cape Cod Chips
Original, 40% reduced fat, BBQ, sea salt and vinegar.
Doritos Chips
Nacho cheese and cool ranch.
Brazilian Chicken
Potato Salad
3 Bean Mango Salad
Pesto Pasta Salad
Chicken Salad
Coleslaw
Sun-Dried Tomato Pasta Salad
Tuna Salad
Lentil Salad
Side Salad
Your Favorite Sandwiches
Applewood Smoked Turkey Breast Sandwich
Brie cheese, honey mustard, plum tomatoes and leaf lettuce on a crispy Parisian baguette.
Turkey Avocado Sandwich
Turkey breast, avocado, lettuce, tomato, herb mayo on sourdough.
Traditional Tuna Salad Sandwich
White albacore tuna tossed with mayonnaise and celery, topped with oven roasted Red Peppers, plum tomatoes and leaf lettuce on a whole grain baguette.
Tuna Salad Club Sandwich
Albacore tuna salad, sliced Hard Boiled egg, plum tomato and green leaf lettuce on white toast.
California Turkey Pita Sandwich
Smoked Turkey with avocado, tomato, sprouts, cucumber and lemon herb dressing on a low-fat and low-cal whole wheat pita bread.
Chicken Salad Club Sandwich
Crispy bacon, plum tomato and green leaf lettuce on white toast.
Avocado BLT Club Sandwich
Fresh ripe avocado, crispy bacon, plum tomato and green leaf lettuce on white toast with mayonnaise.
Our New York Signature Sandwich
Lean steamed corned beef or pastrami sliced to order and piled high on Jewish rye bread. Served with Gulden's deli mustard, coleslaw and kosher pickles.
All Natural Turkey Pita Sandwich
Smoked Turkey, tomatoes, organic mesclun and low-fat mayo on a whole wheat pita. Low-cal.
Our Gourmet Suggestion Sandwich
Imported smoked Norwegian salmon with chive cream cheese and cucumber on Russian black bread.
Hickory Smoked Turkey Pita Sandwich
Smoked Turkey, green leaf lettuce and plum tomato with honey mustard in a pita. Low-cal.
Tuna Pita Sandwich
White albacore tuna salad, sliced tomatoes and mixed greens on a whole wheat pita. Low-cal.
Pico De Gallo Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken, cheddar, avocado, lettuce, tomato, herb mayo on sourdough.
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Muenster cheese, arugula, tomatoes, sliced apples and Dijonnaise dressing on ciabatta.
Turkey Burger
Our Turkey burger seasoned and drilled perfectly. Served topped with avocado, pico de gallo, provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato on a toasted bun. Served with steak fries.
Beef, Turkey, Or Veggie Burger
Severed with lettuce & tomato.
Hickory BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
Unforgettable! Our great burger grilled with our special hickory BBQ sauce smothered with caramelized onions and topped with crispy bacon and cheddar cheese. Served with steak fries.
Burger Deluxe
Served with our steak fries, lettuce, tomato, sliced red onion and kosher dill pickle.
Mexican Burger
Our chef's homemade Mexican style beef burger, served with pico de gallo, guacamole, pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickle. Served with spicy steak fries.
Santa Fe Burger
Think tex-mex our burger with chipotle sauce, crispy bacon, pepper Jack cheese and salsa. Served with spicy steak fries.
Cheeseburger Deluxe With Can Soda Free
Veggie Burger
Vegetarian. Our chef's homemade vegetarian delight. Served on toasted multigrain baguette with pesto sauce, lettuce and tomato. Served with your choice of steak fries or grilled vegetable.
Burgers
Freshly Baked Bagels
Cream Cheese
Smoked Norwegian Salmon With Cream Cheese Bagel
Peanut Butter Bagel
Jelly Bagel
Plain Bagel
Vegetable Cream Cheese Bagel
Vegetarian.
Scallion Cream Cheese Bagel
Lox Spread
Butter Bagel
Grilled Cheese With Bacon Sandwich
Louisiana Hot Chicken Wings
Served with steak fries and Maytag blue cheese dressing.
Grilled Cheese With Ham Sandwich
Kebab
Charcoal broiled chunks of chicken kebab over rice with BBQ sauce or lemon juice.
Grilled Chicken Deluxe Sandwich
Served on a toasted seeded bun with lettuce, tomatoes and crispy stick fries.
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Prime roast beef, grilled mushrooms, peppers, onions and melted cheese on a semolina hero.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich With Steak Fries
Tuna Melt Sandwich
Our albacore tuna salad served open face with melted American or Swiss on white bread.
Crispy Chicken Fingers
Served with sweet potato fries, BBQ sauce and our homemade honey mustard sauce.
Reuben Sandwich
Corned beef or fresh Turkey, served open face with sauerkraut and melted Swiss on Jewish rye bread.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Fish Fillet On Sole Deluxe Sandwich
Served on a toasted seeded bun, with lettuce, tomatoes and tartar sauce and crispy fries.
From Our Grill
Cold Beverages
Honest Tea
Bottled Water
Freshly Squeezed Lemonade
Freshly Squeezed Juice
Vitamin Water
Choose your flavor.
Iced Coffee
20 Oz. Soda
Gatorade
Tropicana Orange Juice
Snapple
Omelette Platter (3 Eggs)
Cheese, western, meat lovers, Greek, California, garden, florentine, or lox.
Egg Platter
2 Eggs served with potatoes and toast. Add bacon, ham or sausage.
Egg Sandwich
2 eggs (any style) add cheese or meat.
Grilled Cheese With French Fries
Create Your Own Omelette Platter (3 Eggs)
Choose any three toppings.
Cinnamon Challah French Toast
Egg White Wraps
On whole wheat, spinach, sun dried tomato, or white flour wrap.
Fluffy Buttermilk Pancakes
Hearty Breakfast
Organic Rotisserie Chicken
Organic Rotisserie Chicken With Sides
Comes with 2 sides.
Chicken Italiano Panini
Grilled chicken breast, fresh mozzarella cheese, lemon roasted garlic spread, caramelized onions and sweet peppers.
Italian Club Panini
Turkey, ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, red onions and garlic aioli on Napolitano Italian bread.
Chicken Panini With Can Soda
Tuscan Melt Panini
Fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto mayo on Napoli flatbread.
Tuna Melt Panini
Our albacore tuna salad with roasted Red Peppers and American cheese on 5-grain whole wheat flatbread.
Smoked Turkey Melt Panini
Grilled vegetable ratatouille and pesto mayo with melted Swiss cheese on focaccia.
Turkey Bacon Guacamole Panini
Real Turkey breast, crispy smoked bacon, pepper Jack cheese, guacamole and ranch dressing in a sourdough panini.
Sierra Turkey Panini
Fresh roasted Turkey with pepper Jack cheese and south western chipotle sauce on 5-grain bread.
Grilled Chicken Tijuana Panini
Mexican grilled chicken breast, chipotle BBQ sauce, grilled peppers and onions with Monterey Jack cheese on rustic focaccia.
Chicken Milano Panini
Charbroiled chicken breast with fresh mozzarella and pesto mayo on Romano focaccia.
Baked Chicken Parmigiana Panini
Tender chicken cutlet, breaded and oven-baked with our fresh homemade marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese and 7 fresh basil in an Italian hero.
Cubano Panini
Oven roasted ham, fresh Turkey, Swiss cheese, dill pickle chips and Russian dressing on Crespino flatbread.
Panini
Pastry, Cookies and Bars
Strawberry Cheesecake
Fat-Free Muffin
High fiber bran, blueberry, triple berry, corn.
Croissant
Plain, filled with chocolate, apple, almonds.
Bars
Cookies
Cannoli
Cupcake
Scones
Blueberry, chocolate chip, cranberry, raisin.
Yogurt Loaf
Banana walnut, lemon king, double chocolate , marble.
Eclair
Cinnamon Bun
Danishes
Cinnamon, raisins, cheese, apple turnover.
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Muffin
Honey raisin bran, orange cranberry, old fashioned blueberry, banana walnut, chocolate chip, corn.
Cheesecake
Hot Oatmeal
Includes 3 toppings. Add extra toppings for an additional charge.
Grilled Cheese With French Fries
Egg Sandwich
2 eggs (any style) add cheese or meat.
Create Your Own Omelette Platter (3 Eggs)
Choose any three toppings.
Egg White Wraps
On whole wheat, spinach, sun dried tomato, or white flour wrap.
Fresh Fruit Salad
Seasonal fruits and melon with mixed berries.
Omelette Platter (3 Eggs)
Cheese, western, meat lovers, Greek, California, garden, florentine, or lox.
Hearty Breakfast - After 11 AM
Hot Beverages
Mochaccino
Espresso
Cafe Au Lait
Flavored Gourmet Coffees
Cappuccino
Decaf House Blend
Tea
Hot Chocolate
Colombian House Blend
Herbal Tea
Cafe Latte
Southwestern Chicken Salad
Slow-roasted cajun chicken, Santa Fe corn salad and garni over baby organic greens.
Greek Salad
Oriental Chicken Salad
Tender chicken in light ginger sesame dressing with Chinese noodles, oriental vegetables and water chestnuts over house salad. Low fat.
Grilled Chicken Over Caesar Salad
Grilled breast of chicken over our crisp, refreshing Caesar salad.
Gotham Chopped Salad
Chicken breast, country ham, hard-cooked eggs, tomatoes, bacon, cheddar cheese and swiss cheese over iceberg lettuce.